Is DPA Forgivable

Is DPA Forgivable

Is DPA Forgivable Under the Chenoa Fund Program?

One of the most common questions homebuyers ask is, “Is DPA forgivable?” when exploring the Chenoa Fund. Down payment assistance can significantly reduce upfront costs, but whether it must be repaid depends on the specific program structure and terms. Understanding how the Chenoa Fund treats forgiveness, repayment, and long-term obligations helps borrowers set clear expectations and choose the option that best supports their homeownership goals.

Navigating the complexities of down payment assistance (DPA) programs is a critical step for many prospective homebuyers. The Chenoa Fund, administered by CBC Mortgage Agency (CBCMA), is one of the most prominent national programs offering such assistance. A common and crucial question for borrowers is whether this financial aid is a gift that vanishes or a loan that must be repaid.

The short answer is: Yes, the Chenoa Fund offers forgivable down payment assistance options, but forgiveness is not automatic for every product. The program offers distinct paths—some designed to be forgiven after a set period of good payment behavior, and others designed to be repaid in monthly installments. Understanding the specific terms, conditions, and “trigger events” that determine forgivability is essential for homeowners to avoid unexpected debts down the road.

This article explores the mechanics of the Chenoa Fund’s forgivable and repayable options, detailing the requirements for forgiveness, the “reset” provision, and the scenarios where repayment becomes mandatory.

The Two Main Paths: Forgivable vs. Repayable

The Chenoa Fund provides down payment assistance in the form of a second mortgage. This second mortgage is paired with an FHA-insured first mortgage to cover 3.5% or 5% of the home’s purchase price or appraised value. When a borrower applies for the Chenoa Fund, they generally select between two product structures: the Forgivable Second Mortgage and the Repayable Second Mortgage.

It is important to note that the assistance is never structured as a simple “grant” or “gift” at the closing table. It is legally recorded as a lien against the property. Whether that lien is eventually released without payment depends on the path chosen.

1. The Forgivable Second Mortgage (Soft Second)
This option is designed for borrowers who intend to occupy the home for several years and maintain a consistent payment history. It is often referred to as a “soft second” because it has “soft” repayment terms compared to a standard loan.

  • Interest Rate: The interest rate on the forgivable second mortgage is 0%. This means the loan balance does not accrue interest over time; the amount owed remains equal to the original assistance amount provided at closing.
  • Monthly Payments: There are no monthly payments required. The borrower does not need to budget for this second mortgage on a monthly basis.
  • Loan Term: The loan has a term of 30 years. However, the expectation is that the loan will be forgiven long before the 30-year mark is reached, provided the borrower meets specific conditions.

2. The Repayable Second Mortgage
This option functions like a traditional loan. It is typically chosen by borrowers who may not qualify for the forgivable product (due to income limits) or who prefer a shorter amortization schedule.

  • Forgiveness: This loan is not forgivable. The borrower is contractually obligated to repay the full principal balance plus interest.
  • Interest Rate: The interest rate is typically set 1% higher than the interest rate on the FHA first mortgage.
  • Monthly Payments: The borrower must make monthly principal and interest payments.
  • Loan Term: The loan is fully amortized over a 10-year term.
Conditions for Forgiveness​

Conditions for Forgiveness

For borrowers who select the forgivable option, the debt is erased only if specific behavioral requirements are met regarding the payment of the first mortgage.

The 36-Month Rule
Under current guidelines (Correspondent Seller Guide Version 12.27), forgiveness for both the 3.5% and 5% down payment assistance amounts occurs after the borrower makes 36 consecutive, on-time payments on the FHA first mortgage.
• Consecutive: The payments must be made in a row. A break in the chain of on-time payments stops the progress toward forgiveness.
• On-Time: “On-time” is generally defined as the payment being received within the month it is due and not becoming 30 days or more delinquent.
• The Reward: Once the 36th consecutive payment is made, the principal balance of the second mortgage is forgiven. The lien is released, and the borrower no longer owes the money to CBC Mortgage Agency. Note that forgiveness is not always automatic; the borrower may need to request forgiveness and pay a fee for processing the lien release once the conditions are satisfied.

The “Reset” Provision
One of the unique and borrower-friendly features of the Chenoa Fund is the “reset” provision. If a borrower fails to maintain the streak of 36 consecutive payments, they do not necessarily lose the opportunity for forgiveness forever.
If a borrower makes a payment on the first mortgage that is 30 days or more delinquent, the 36-month forgiveness counter resets to zero. The borrower must then start a new streak of 36 consecutive on-time payments to qualify for forgiveness. This opportunity to reset and try again remains open for the entire 30-year term of the loan. As long as the borrower can achieve that 3-year period of perfect payment history while the loan is active, the debt can be forgiven.

When is the Assistance NOT Forgiven?

Even if a borrower selects the forgivable product, there are scenarios where the loan must be repaid in full. Understanding these “trigger events” is vital for financial planning.

  1. Early Sale or Transfer
    If the borrower sells the home or transfers the title to another party before the forgiveness conditions (36 consecutive payments) are met, the loan is not forgiven. The full amount of the down payment assistance becomes due and payable immediately upon the sale. Since the loan has 0% interest, the amount due is simply the original principal amount borrowed.
  2. Refinancing the First Mortgage
    Refinancing is a major trigger event. The Chenoa Fund second mortgage is designed to exist alongside the specific FHA first mortgage it was paired with.
    • General Rule: If the borrower refinances the first mortgage before the forgiveness period is complete, the second mortgage typically must be paid off.
    • Loss of Forgivable Status: If the borrower refinances the first mortgage during the initial 36-month period, and state law allows the second mortgage to subordinate (stay attached to the property in second place) without CBC Mortgage Agency’s consent, the loan permanently loses its forgivable status. In this scenario, the loan remains a 0% interest loan with no monthly payments, but the debt will never be forgiven. It must eventually be repaid upon a future sale, another refinance, or at the end of the 30-year term.
  3. Failure to Meet Conditions by Maturity
    If the borrower stays in the home for 30 years but never manages to string together 36 consecutive on-time payments (perhaps due to frequent late payments that constantly reset the clock), the loan will technically mature at the end of the 30-year term. However, guidelines suggest that if the forgiveness condition is not met before the end of the term, the loan may be forgiven at the borrower’s request upon payment of the lien release processing fee, provided the specific clawback provisions regarding refinancing haven’t been triggered.

Choosing the Right Option

The decision between a forgivable and a repayable loan often comes down to income eligibility and long-term goals.
• Income Limits: The forgivable option often has stricter qualifying criteria. While some documentation suggests no income limits “at this time,” historical iterations and specific sub-products (like “Rate Advantage”) often cap eligibility at 115% or 135% of the Area Median Income (AMI). The repayable option generally has no income limits, making it the only choice for high-income earners.
• Interest Rates: The repayable loan carries an interest rate 1% higher than the first mortgage. This means the borrower pays interest on the assistance. The forgivable loan has 0% interest.
• Refinance Plans: Borrowers who plan to refinance their home within a year or two (perhaps to remove FHA mortgage insurance or lower their rate) should be wary of the forgivable option. Since forgiveness requires a 36-month commitment to the original loan, an early refinance would trigger a repayment requirement, negating the benefit of the “gift”.

Choosing the Right Option​

The Chenoa Fund down payment assistance is forgivable, provided the borrower selects the correct product type (the 30-year, 0% interest second mortgage) and adheres to a strict payment schedule. By making 36 consecutive on-time payments on their FHA first mortgage, borrowers can have the entire second lien extinguished.

However, this forgiveness is earned, not guaranteed. Late payments reset the clock, and selling or refinancing the home early triggers a requirement to repay the funds. For borrowers who do not meet the criteria for the forgivable product, or who choose the repayable option, the assistance acts as a standard 10-year loan that must be repaid in monthly installments.

FAQ's

Forgiveness is not automatically processed the moment the 36th payment clears. Once you have successfully made 36 consecutive, on-time payments on your first mortgage, you must actively request forgiveness from CBC Mortgage Agency. You will typically need to contact the servicing department (often via email at servicing@chenoafund.org) to initiate the review of your payment history. Upon verification that the conditions have been met, you will generally be required to pay a processing fee to cover the administrative costs of preparing and recording the lien release, at which point the debt is officially extinguished.

No, the balance of the forgivable second mortgage does not grow over time. This product carries an interest rate of 0%. This means that if you trigger a repayment event—such as selling your home in year two—you will only be responsible for repaying the original principal amount of the assistance provided. There is no accrued interest to pay back. This contrasts with the Repayable Second Mortgage, which carries an interest rate higher than the first mortgage and involves paying significant interest over the life of the 10-year loan term.

No, the Repayable Second Mortgage is a distinct product from the Forgivable Second Mortgage and does not offer a forgiveness feature. If you choose the repayable option—often selected by borrowers with higher incomes who exceed the limits for the forgivable product—you are taking on a fully amortizing loan. This loan has a 10-year term and requires monthly principal and interest payments. The interest rate is typically set 1% higher than your first mortgage rate. You are contractually obligated to pay off the entire balance over the 10-year period, regardless of your payment history or how long you stay in the home.

If you sell your home or transfer the title to another party before you have satisfied the forgiveness conditions (making 36 consecutive on-time payments), the loan is not forgiven. Instead, the full principal amount of the down payment assistance becomes immediately due and payable. Because the forgivable product carries a 0% interest rate, you would typically only owe the original amount borrowed, without accrued interest. This debt must be paid off from the proceeds of the sale at closing, just like your primary mortgage or any other lien attached to the property title.

Refinancing your first mortgage is a major “trigger event” that can jeopardize the forgivable nature of the assistance. Generally, if you refinance the first mortgage before the 36-month forgiveness period is complete, the second mortgage permanently loses its forgivable status. In this scenario, the loan remains a 0% interest loan with no monthly payments, but the debt will never be forgiven. It essentially becomes a “silent” balloon loan that must be repaid in full upon a future sale, a subsequent refinance, or at the end of the 30-year term. Subordination of the lien is typically not allowed during the initial forgiveness period.

Yes, under the most recent program guidelines (Version 12.27), the forgiveness terms have been unified for both assistance levels. Whether you receive 3.5% or 5% down payment assistance, the forgiveness requirement is 36 consecutive, on-time payments on your FHA first mortgage. In the past, some variations of the program may have required a longer period (such as 10 years) for the higher 5% assistance amount, but current standards apply the 36-month rule to both. However, borrowers should always verify the specific terms listed in their final loan documents, as older product variations might still exist in the marketplace.

No, if you choose the forgivable second mortgage option, you are not required to make monthly payments on the assistance balance. This loan is structured with a 0% interest rate and a 30-year term, but it sits in a “silent” second position. As long as you remain in the home and are working toward the forgiveness conditions on your first mortgage, this second lien requires no monthly cash flow from you. This feature is designed to keep your monthly housing obligations lower during the early years of homeownership, provided you do not trigger a repayment event like a sale or refinance.

The Chenoa Fund includes a “reset” provision that acts as a safety net for borrowers. If you make a payment on your first mortgage that is 30 days or more delinquent during the initial 36-month forgiveness period, you do not automatically default on the assistance loan. Instead, the 36-month forgiveness counter resets to zero. You remain eligible for forgiveness, but you must start a new streak of 36 consecutive on-time payments. This reset option remains available for the entire 30-year term of the loan, giving you multiple opportunities to demonstrate the payment stability required to have the debt erased.

For the assistance to be forgiven, you must demonstrate a consistent history of on-time payments on your first mortgage. Under current program guidelines, forgiveness for both the 3.5% and 5% assistance amounts occurs after you make 36 consecutive, on-time payments on your FHA first mortgage. “On-time” is generally defined as the payment being made within the month it is due and not becoming 30 days or more delinquent. It is crucial to maintain this streak without interruption; otherwise, the countdown to forgiveness will stop, and you will be required to restart the qualifying period from the beginning.

Technically, the Chenoa Fund down payment assistance is not structured as an upfront gift or grant at the closing table. Instead, it is legally recorded as a second mortgage lien against your property. This ensures that the borrower adheres to specific requirements regarding occupancy and payment history. However, if you select the forgivable product option—often referred to as a “soft second”—the loan is designed to eventually function like a gift. Once you meet the specific forgiveness conditions, the principal balance is waived, and the lien is released, meaning you never have to pay back the funds provided for your down payment.

Shining Star Funding

527 Sycamore Valley Rd W, Danville, CA 94526
Toll Free Call : (866) 280-0020

For informational purposes only. No guarantee of accuracy is expressed or implied. Programs shown may not include all options or pricing structures. Rates, terms, programs and underwriting policies subject to change without notice. This is not an offer to extend credit or a commitment to lend. All loans subject to underwriting approval. Some products may not be available in all states and restrictions may apply. Equal Housing Opportunity.
Interactive calculators are self-help tools. Results received from this calculator are designed for comparative and illustrative purposes only, and accuracy is not guaranteed. Shining Star Funding is not responsible for any errors, omissions, or misrepresentations. This calculator does not have the ability to pre-qualify you for any loan program or promotion. Qualification for loan programs may require additional information such as credit scores and cash reserves which is not gathered in this calculator. Information such as interest rates and pricing are subject to change at any time and without notice. Additional fees such as HOA dues are not included in calculations. All information such as interest rates, taxes, insurance, PMI payments, etc. are estimates and should be used for comparison only. Shining Star Funding does not guarantee any of the information obtained by this calculator.

Privacy Policy | Accessibility Statement | Term of Use | NMLS Consumer Access 

CMG Mortgage, Inc. dba Shining Star Funding, NMLS ID# 1820 (www.nmlsconsumeraccess.org, www.cmghomeloans.com), Equal Housing Opportunity. Licensed by the Department of Financial Protection and Innovation (DFPI) under the California Residential Mortgage Lending Act No. 4150025. To verify our complete list of state licenses, please visit www.cmgfi.com/corporate/licensing