Is DPA Forgivable

Is DPA Forgivable

Is Down Payment Assistance (DPA) Forgivable in CalHFA Loan Programs?

Many homebuyers considering CalHFA Loan Programs want to know if their down payment assistance (DPA) is forgivable. Certain CalHFA programs do offer forgivable DPA, meaning the assistance may not need to be repaid if specific conditions are met, such as occupying the home for a set period. Other DPA options, like deferred or shared appreciation loans, require repayment when the home is sold, refinanced, or the mortgage is paid off. Understanding whether a DPA is forgivable helps buyers plan their finances, choose the right program, and make informed decisions on achieving affordable and sustainable homeownership.

For many first-time homebuyers in California, the terminology surrounding down payment assistance can be confusing. Words like “assistance,” “program,” and “help” often imply a grant or a gift—money that is given freely to help you achieve the American Dream. However, when utilizing the programs offered by the California Housing Finance Agency (CalHFA), it is vital to understand the difference between a “grant” and a “deferred-payment loan.”

To answer the most pressing question on the minds of many borrowers: No, the vast majority of CalHFA down payment assistance programs are NOT forgivable.

While there is one specific exception regarding construction grants for Accessory Dwelling Units (ADUs), the primary products used to buy a home—MyHome, ZIP, MyAccess, and Dream For All—are fully repayable debts. They are designed to get you into a home with little cash upfront, but they create a financial obligation that stays with the property until you sell, refinance, or pay it off.

1. The "Silent Second" Concept: Why It Feels Like Forgiveness

The reason many borrowers mistakenly believe these loans are forgivable is that they are structured as deferred-payment loans,,.
When you take out a standard mortgage (your “First Mortgage”), you receive a bill every month. If you stop paying, the bank forecloses. In contrast, CalHFA assistance loans are “silent.”
• No Monthly Bill: You do not make monthly payments on the down payment assistance.
• No Late Fees: Since no payment is due, you cannot be late.
Because these loans sit silently in the background for years, borrowers sometimes assume the debt dissolves over time. This is incorrect. The debt is simply “sleeping” until a specific event wakes it up. The lien is recorded against your property title, ensuring that CalHFA is paid back before you can take any profit from a future sale.

Conditions for Forgiveness​

2. Program-by-Program Repayment Rules

Each CalHFA program has slightly different terms, but they share the core characteristic of being a repayable debt rather than a grant.

A. MyHome Assistance Program
The MyHome program is the standard down payment helper, offering 3.0% to 3.5% of the purchase price or appraised value to cover your entry costs.
• Forgivable? No. The MyHome loan is not forgivable.
• The Cost: It accrues 1.00% simple interest. This is favorable compared to credit cards or standard mortgages because “simple” interest is calculated only on the principal balance, not on the growing interest. However, the balance does grow. If you borrow $10,000, you will owe more than $10,000 when you eventually pay it back.
• When is it due? You must repay the principal and all accrued interest when you sell the home, refinance, or pay off the first mortgage.

B. Zero Interest Program (ZIP)
The ZIP loan is used exclusively for closing costs and is paired with “CalPLUS” mortgages.
• Forgivable? No. The ZIP loan is not forgivable.
• The Cost: This loan has a 0.00% interest rate. This is the closest the program comes to “free” money in terms of interest. If you borrow $8,000 for closing costs, you will owe exactly $8,000 in the future. The amount does not grow, but the original principal must be returned.
• When is it due? Repayment is triggered by the transfer of title, sale of the property, or refinancing of the first mortgage.

C. MyAccess Program
This is a newer layer of assistance paired with CalPLUS Access loans, offering 2.5% of the loan amount.
• Forgivable? No. It functions like the MyHome program.
• The Cost: It carries a 1.00% simple interest rate.
• When is it due? It is due upon sale, transfer, refinance, or full payoff of the first loan.

D. Dream For All Shared Appreciation Loan
This program offers the most substantial assistance (up to 20%), but it comes with the most complex repayment obligation.
• Forgivable? No. It is explicitly stated that this is a loan to be repaid, not a grant.
• The Cost: The interest rate is 0%, but you pay a “share of appreciation”. Instead of paying interest, you pay back the original 20% you borrowed plus 20% (or 15% for lower income) of the increase in the home’s value,.
• When is it due? Like the others, it is due upon sale or transfer. However, unlike the others, it has a unique allowance for a one-time refinance without immediate repayment (discussed in Section 4).

3. The Exception: The ADU Grant Program

There is one specific instance where CalHFA offers funds that do not need to be repaid. This is the Accessory Dwelling Unit (ADU) Grant Program.
• Forgivable? Yes (because it is a Grant). The program provides up to $40,000 for pre-development and non-recurring closing costs to build an ADU (granny flat),.
• Why it’s different: CalHFA provides these funds directly to the construction escrow. The borrower receives a Form 1099-G for tax purposes because the IRS considers this grant as income, but there is no lien recorded against the property requiring repayment of these specific funds.
Note: This grant helps you build an addition to a home you already own or are buying; it is not a down payment assistance loan for the purchase of the primary home itself.

4. "Trigger Events": When You Must Pay

Since you don’t make monthly payments, you need to be aware of the “Trigger Events” that force you to write a check for the full balance of the assistance. Across MyHome, ZIP, MyAccess, and Dream For All, the triggers are nearly identical,,,:

  1. Sale of the Property: When you sell your home, the proceeds from the sale are used to pay off your first mortgage first, followed immediately by the CalHFA assistance loans. You pocket the remaining profit only after these debts are satisfied.
  2. Transfer of Title: If you transfer the deed to someone else (even a family member), the loans become due.
  3. Refinance of the First Mortgage: This is the most common “surprise” for borrowers. If you try to refinance your main mortgage to get a lower interest rate, you are generally required to pay off the assistance loans at that time.
Choosing the Right Option​
  1. Payoff of the First Loan: If you live in the house for 30 years and make your final mortgage payment, the assistance loans become due immediately.
  2. Default: If a Notice of Default is recorded (the start of foreclosure), the loans are accelerated and become due.
  3. The Refinance Trap: Understanding Subordination
    The issue of “forgivability” often comes up when borrowers want to refinance. They assume that because they haven’t sold the house, they can keep the assistance loan in place.
    However, CalHFA has a strict Resubordination Policy:
    • MyHome and ZIP: Subordination is not allowed for standard refinances. This means if interest rates drop and you want to refinance your home, you must have enough equity to pay off the MyHome and ZIP loans in full. You cannot keep them as a second mortgage behind the new lender.
    • Dream For All: This program is the exception. CalHFA allows a one-time re-subordination for a limited cash-out refinance,. This allows Dream For All borrowers to lower their interest rate without being forced to pay back the huge 20% equity share immediately.

Conclusion

For the borrower, the takeaway is clear: CalHFA offers leverage, not charity. Programs like MyHome and ZIP allow you to buy a home sooner by covering the upfront costs that usually take years to save. The trade-off is that these costs are pushed into the future. You are essentially borrowing from your future home equity to buy the house today.
While the loans are not forgivable, the terms are generally much better than private market alternatives (hard money or credit cards). With 1% simple interest (MyHome) or 0% interest (ZIP/Dream For All), the cost of borrowing this money is low. However, you must plan your financial future with the understanding that when you eventually sell or refinance, a portion of your proceeds will go toward settling these debts.

FAQ's

When you sell your home, the proceeds first go to pay off your primary mortgage, followed by any CalHFA subordinate loans (MyHome, ZIP, Dream For All). If the property value has dropped or not appreciated enough to cover the sales costs and these liens, you are typically still responsible for the debt. However, for the Dream For All program specifically, if the home does not appreciate in value, you are generally only responsible for the original principal amount. CalHFA shares in the appreciation, but borrowers generally are not penalized with shared appreciation costs if the home value remains flat.

Yes, for the MyHome and MyAccess programs, you will owe more than the original loan amount. Both programs charge a 1.00% simple interest rate. While this rate is low, it accrues annually. For example, if you borrowed $10,000, you would accrue $100 in interest per year. After 10 years, you would owe the original $10,000 plus $1,000 in accrued interest. This is different from the ZIP loan, which has 0% interest (you pay back exactly what you borrowed), and the Dream For All, where the repayment amount depends entirely on the market value of your home.

Yes, the Accessory Dwelling Unit (ADU) Grant Program is the primary exception. This program provides up to $40,000 to assist with pre-development and non-recurring closing costs for building an ADU. Unlike the down payment assistance products, this is a true grant and does not require repayment. However, because it is not a loan, the IRS treats the grant funds as taxable income. Borrowers who utilize this program will receive a Form 1099-G and should consult with a tax professional regarding the tax implications of receiving these funds for their construction project.

You are required to repay CalHFA assistance loans immediately upon the occurrence of a “trigger event.” The most common triggers include selling the property to a third party, transferring the title to a spouse or family member, or refinancing your first mortgage (with the limited exception for Dream For All). Additionally, if you live in the home for the full 30-year term and pay off your first mortgage, the subordinate loans become due immediately. Finally, if the property goes into foreclosure (a Notice of Default is formally recorded), the assistance loans are accelerated and become due and payable.

Generally, no. For the MyHome, ZIP, and MyAccess programs, CalHFA usually does not allow subordination for a standard voluntary refinance. This means if you want to refinance your first mortgage to get a lower interest rate, you are required to pay off the assistance loans in full as part of the transaction. The only exception is the Dream For All Shared Appreciation Loan, which allows for a one-time limited cash-out refinance where the state will agree to remain in the second lien position, allowing you to lower your rate without immediately paying back the appreciation share.

The Dream For All loan is unique because you repay the original principal plus a share of the home’s appreciation instead of traditional interest. If your home increases in value, you will owe the 20% principal you borrowed plus a percentage of that growth (typically 20%, or 15% for lower-income borrowers). The total repayment amount is capped at 2.5 times the original loan amount. This loan is not forgivable; if you sell the home or transfer title, CalHFA collects its share of the equity to reinvest in future homebuyers. Repayment is deferred until sale, transfer, or refinancing.

While the Zero Interest Program (ZIP) offers a 0.00% interest rate, it is not “free money” or a grant; it is a loan that must be repaid. Because the interest rate is zero, the amount you owe in the future will be exactly the same amount you borrowed at closing; the balance does not grow over time. However, like other CalHFA subordinate loans, the ZIP lien must be satisfied upon the sale, refinance, or transfer of the home. It essentially acts as an interest-free bridge loan to help you cover closing costs without depleting your personal savings.

The MyHome Assistance Program is a loan, not a gift. It carries a simple interest rate of 1.00%. “Simple interest” means interest is calculated only on the principal balance, not on previously accrued interest, making it less expensive than compound interest debts. Repayment of the principal plus all accrued interest is required when you sell the property, refinance your first mortgage, transfer the title to another person, or pay off the first mortgage in full. Because it is not forgivable, you must account for this future payoff amount when calculating your potential equity upon selling the home.

No, you do not need to make monthly payments on CalHFA subordinate loans. Programs like MyHome, ZIP, MyAccess, and the Dream For All Shared Appreciation Loan feature fully deferred payments for the life of the loan (typically 30 years). This structure is designed to keep your monthly housing costs affordable by ensuring your monthly obligation is limited to your first mortgage payment (principal, interest, taxes, and insurance). However, even though no bill is sent monthly, the loan is still active, and interest (or appreciation) may be accumulating in the background until the loan is eventually paid off.

No, generally speaking, CalHFA down payment assistance options like MyHome, ZIP, MyAccess, and the Dream For All Shared Appreciation Loan are not forgivable grants. They are structured as deferred-payment subordinate loans. This means you are borrowing the money to cover your upfront costs, and a lien is recorded against your property title. While you do not have to make monthly payments on these loans, the debt remains owed to the agency. You are required to repay the full principal balance, plus any accrued interest or shared appreciation, when a specific trigger event occurs, such as selling the home or refinancing.

Shining Star Funding

527 Sycamore Valley Rd W, Danville, CA 94526
Toll Free Call : (866) 280-0020

For informational purposes only. No guarantee of accuracy is expressed or implied. Programs shown may not include all options or pricing structures. Rates, terms, programs and underwriting policies subject to change without notice. This is not an offer to extend credit or a commitment to lend. All loans subject to underwriting approval. Some products may not be available in all states and restrictions may apply. Equal Housing Opportunity.
Interactive calculators are self-help tools. Results received from this calculator are designed for comparative and illustrative purposes only, and accuracy is not guaranteed. Shining Star Funding is not responsible for any errors, omissions, or misrepresentations. This calculator does not have the ability to pre-qualify you for any loan program or promotion. Qualification for loan programs may require additional information such as credit scores and cash reserves which is not gathered in this calculator. Information such as interest rates and pricing are subject to change at any time and without notice. Additional fees such as HOA dues are not included in calculations. All information such as interest rates, taxes, insurance, PMI payments, etc. are estimates and should be used for comparison only. Shining Star Funding does not guarantee any of the information obtained by this calculator.

Privacy Policy | Accessibility Statement | Term of Use | NMLS Consumer Access 

CMG Mortgage, Inc. dba Shining Star Funding, NMLS ID# 1820 (www.nmlsconsumeraccess.org, www.cmghomeloans.com), Equal Housing Opportunity. Licensed by the Department of Financial Protection and Innovation (DFPI) under the California Residential Mortgage Lending Act No. 4150025. To verify our complete list of state licenses, please visit www.cmgfi.com/corporate/licensing